Russia and China's Dueling Plans to Aid Palestinians Amid Israel-Hamas Conflict

Russia's proposition has garnered support from various Arab states and focuses on advocating for a humanitarian ceasefire. This call for a cessation of hostilities seeks to create a temporary respite in the ongoing violence

Russia has plans for Gaza humanitarian aid - Photo by Michael Parulava / Unsplash

In the midst of the ongoing Israel-Hamas conflict in the Gaza Strip, two major world powers, Russia and China, have put forth competing initiatives at the United Nations to alleviate the plight of Palestinian civilians. As of October 24, 2023, these divergent proposals shed light on the complex dynamics of the Middle East conflict and the involvement of global players.

Russian Push for a Humanitarian Ceasefire

Russia's proposition has garnered support from various Arab states and focuses on advocating for a humanitarian ceasefire. This call for a cessation of hostilities seeks to create a temporary respite in the ongoing violence, with the primary aim of safeguarding the lives and well-being of the Palestinian population caught in the crossfire. The backing of Arab nations underscores the gravity of the humanitarian situation in Gaza and the need for an immediate halt to the violence.

China's Critique of Israel's Actions and Humanitarian Concerns

In contrast, China has chosen to take a more critical stance towards Israel's actions in the conflict. China's leaders have voiced concerns that Israel's actions have "gone beyond self-defense," suggesting that the country's military response may have escalated beyond what could be justified as a defensive measure. This perspective aligns with broader international discussions regarding the proportionality of Israel's actions in response to attacks from Hamas.

Furthermore, China has expressed "deep disappointment" with the United States for vetoing a UN Security Council resolution that called for a humanitarian pause in the fighting. This veto, according to China, hinders the international community's ability to address the pressing humanitarian needs in Gaza effectively.

A Display of Political Influence and Diplomacy

Both Russia and China's involvement in this crisis should be viewed in the broader context of their historical support for the Palestinian cause. These two countries have consistently advocated for the rights and well-being of the Palestinian people, and the current conflict presents an opportunity for them to reaffirm their positions and assert their political influence on the global stage.

China's Growing Role in the Middle East

China's increasing involvement in the Middle East holds several key implications. Firstly, it has been actively engaged in Syria's reconstruction efforts and has made substantial investments in energy and infrastructure projects in Iraq. Additionally, China is contributing to major projects, such as building Cairo's new administrative capital and constructing the new metro system in Mecca, underlining its expanding influence in the region.

Economic and Energy Interests

China's economic interests in the Middle East are multifaceted. It is the largest purchaser of Middle Eastern oil globally, with Middle Eastern producers accounting for a significant portion of its total oil imports. This economic interdependence has solidified its position as a major player in the region. Moreover, China has become the primary source of foreign investment in the Middle East and a vital economic partner for several Gulf states, particularly Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.

Diplomatic Role and Brokering Peace

China's stance on the Middle East conflict is notable for its commitment to a two-state solution based on the 1967 borders, with East Jerusalem recognized as the Palestinian capital. This position aligns with international consensus and emphasizes China's aspiration to play a diplomatic role in resolving the region's long-standing conflicts.

A Responsible Global Power

China's increasing involvement in Middle Eastern affairs is in line with its broader foreign policy strategy. It aims to bolster its global influence and be recognized as a responsible global power. In contrast to some other international actors, China places a strong emphasis on diplomacy and dialogue, preferring peaceful means to address conflicts rather than military interventions.

Read More From WorldFuture

Historical Baggage and International Standing

China's approach in the Middle East is often seen as carrying less historical baggage than certain Western powers, particularly the United States. This perception can sometimes facilitate its diplomatic efforts in the region, as it is not burdened by colonial legacies or historical entanglements that have characterized the policies of some Western nations.

In conclusion, Russia and China's competing plans at the United Nations reflect their deepening involvement in the Middle East and their desire to shape the region's future. As the Israel-Hamas conflict continues, these global powers are actively positioning themselves as diplomatic brokers and humanitarian advocates, adding complexity to an already intricate geopolitical landscape.